Why Subway is closing stores to repair a franchise system built on scale
Subway still had more U.S. restaurants than Starbucks or McDonald's in 2026, yet by then its U.S. store count had fallen for ten straight years. That makes it unusual. Most chains treat store count as proof of health, while Subway shows what can happen when a low-cost franchise spreads further than demand can support. Management now describes the closures as rightsizing.
Paid on sales, not on store profit
Subway earns its money from franchisees rather than from running stores. Entrepreneur's franchise listing, last updated in 2022, shows an 8% royalty and a 4.5% advertising fee, or 12.5% in total, plus an initial fee of up to $15,000. Because fees like these come off sales, the franchisor gets paid before a store knows whether it made a profit. A franchise disclosure filing reviewed by FOX Business showed total franchise revenue down more than 6% to $767 million in 2025, while net income rose to $688 million from $397 million in 2024 and $15 million in 2023. The report did not explain why profit rose as franchise revenue fell, so that gap is best treated as an open question.
Two customers with different needs
Sandwich buyers pay for a made-to-order meal, and in 2026 Subway was rolling out a value menu with 15 items under $5. Franchisees pay for something else: a recognized brand with a modest entry cost, with Entrepreneur's 2022 listing showing an investment range of $263,000 to $630,000. That accessibility suited rapid expansion, and the chain peaked at nearly 45,000 locations worldwide in 2016. About 36,000 remained in 2024, when Roark Capital finalized its purchase for a reported $9.6 billion after a Federal Trade Commission review linked to Roark's stakes in rivals such as Jimmy John's and McAlister's Deli. Jonathan Fitzpatrick, a former Burger King executive who went on to lead Driven Brands, became CEO in July 2025.
What rivals cannot easily replicate
Reach is still Subway's main asset. It opened more than 1,000 locations worldwide in 2025 and says it had agreements in place for 12,000 more units in 2026. A simple store template that local operators can repeat is hard for smaller sandwich brands to match abroad. The McDonald's Business Model Canvas and Burger King Business Model Canvas show how other large franchise systems balance unit count against sales per store, and the general Franchise Model Business Model Canvas explains the basic trade between brand owner and operator.
The risk: franchisor income and store health can drift apart
The weak point is store-level sales. Circana's 2026 rankings put the average Subway location at about $500,000 a year, and its 2025 ranking showed the lowest average unit volumes of the 50 chains it analyzed. At those 2026 volumes, the combined 12.5% in listed fees is a heavy load. Subway closed a net 729 U.S. restaurants in 2025 and ended that year with fewer than 19,000. It opened 499 locations in 2025, but more than half were previously shuttered units, and about 800 sites were temporarily closed at the end of 2025. Its filing pointed to only about 100 new U.S. openings in 2026. Competition adds pressure: Circana's 2025 ranking showed consumer spending down 6% at Subway while it rose 16% at Jersey Mike's. If owners keep leaving, royalty income eventually follows, whatever the headline profit shows in a given year.
Sources
- FOX 32 Chicago: Subway closes 729 US locations in 2025, marking steepest decline in years
- Entrepreneur: Subway Had to Close 729 More Stores
- Entrepreneur: Subway franchise listing
- Entrepreneur: After Months of Scrutiny, Roark Capital Finalizes $9.6 Billion Subway Acquisition
- Restaurant Dive: Subway taps Burger King vet as CEO
Last reviewed: November 2026.
